Was slavery a necessary evil

TotalInMassachusetts became the first colony to authorize slavery through enacted law. Colonists came to equate this term with Native Americans and Africans.

Was slavery a necessary evil

Dec 03,  · The slavery is evil, is necessary if we accept that all human beings have equal rights. If it was not accepted before , it was because they didn't accept equal rights for human beings. And slavery was not only about black heartoftexashop.com: Resolved. The Defense of Slavery. A. How did the South Defend Slavery? 1. Before - The South defended slavery as a necessary evil. They argued that the emergence of cotton as the most important cash crop in the country made slaves necessary. 2. After - A number of factors (outlined below) forced southerners to change their defense. Slavery in the United States was the legal institution of human chattel enslavement, primarily of Africans and African Americans, "A necessary evil" In the 19th century, proponents of slavery often defended the institution as a "necessary evil". White people of that time feared that emancipation of black slaves would have more harmful.

From the eighteenth century slavery had been regarded as a moral evil by many people; and there had always been societies, animated by amiable humanitarian impulses, devoted to a mild sort of emancipation propaganda.

But inwhen William Lloyd Garrison established the Liberator in Boston, the opposition to slavery was taken up by a different sort of men and in a radically different spirit. Previously, the South had had little to fear from the prevailing Northern sentiment that slavery was in itself an evil, but that in the South, and under present conditions, it was probably a necessary evil for which the slaveowners were not to be held morally responsible, and which they must be left to deal with as time and circumstances might determine.

Garrison and the "Abolitionists" altogether repudiated such views. To say that slavery was a necessary evil was no reflection upon Southern planters.

They had commonly, beforesaid as much themselves. Many things in this world are necessary evils and are complacently accepted as such.

Get Full Essay

It could be said, and was said, that the wretched condition of factory laborers in New England and old England cotton-mills was a necessary evil. But it was a different matter when people began to denounce slavery as an unnecessary evil, as a crime against humanity.

Slave-owners might think the charge absurd, and as long as Abolition sentiment was confined to a few fanatics they could ignore it with contempt. The Abolitionist argument could be adequately met only by proving that slavery was a positive good, an institution that harmonized with the nature of things, a social arrangement which was a blessing to society and a benefit to the slave.

Between and serious and humane and gifted men formulated such a defense of slavery. They were only following a marked trend of thought throughout the world when they maintained that the phrases of the Declaration of Independence were no more than "glittering generalities.

The exclusive owners of property ever have been, ever will, and perhaps ever ought to be the virtual rulers of mankind. It is the order of nature and of God that the being of superior faculties and knowledge, and therefore of superior power, should control and dispose of those who are inferior.

It is as much the order of nature that men should enslave each other as that animals should prey upon each other. There was a wage-slavery as well as a chattel slavery, and the South maintained that the former was worse than the latter.

In James H. Hammond published a series of letters in which he drew a heartrending picture of the condition of laborers in the great industrial centers. Since subjection was thus the essential basis of civilized society, that system was best where the master was responsible for the slave.

Instead, therefore, of abolishing negro slavery in the South, this system should be taken as the model for the reform of industrial conditions in the North.

Slavery As A Necessary Evil Essay Sample

The capitalists, according to Mr. Hammond, should become the owners of their laborers and as such be compelled to clothe and feed them decently; while in the West the public lands should be parceled out in great estates and tilled by the landless poor bound in perpetuity to the soil.

As this philosophy came to be the accepted social and political faith throughout the South, its advocates ceased to be content with the negative policy of preserving slavery where it already existed.

For Southern extremists, no less than for Northern extremists, the slavery question became a moral issue, capable only of a logical and a radical solution.

One thing which may be said of the various sacred books of the world is, that just as soon and just so far as a people have come to regard any book as sacred, they have begun to be blind to its faults, to take it as an ultimatum, and to be unwilling to seek for, or even to receive, anything as by any possibility better than it.

Not all historians would agree that slavery was a "necessary" evil. In colonial America, slavery was a cheaper option was to running plantations than hiring laborers. Before - The South defended slavery as a necessary evil. They argued that the emergence of cotton as the most important cash crop . Slavery As A Necessary Evil Essay Sample. It is inevitable that with the mention of slavery emotions will be aroused within whoever is present. Today most people look at slavery as one of the biggest mistakes our country has ever made.

Thereafter its eyes are not turned forward but backward. Everything thenceforth must be estimated as good or bad, according as it does or does not agree with the teaching of the Book. Hence the strange fact that so many excellent Christian people in America defended slavery as something good and right.

It happened that the people from whom the Old Testament part of our sacred book came, held slaves, and, in common with most other nations in that early age of the world, thought it right so to do.

The centuries that passed since that time had carried the world forward to the point where all the leading nations saw plainly that slavery is wrong.

Was slavery a necessary evil

But the fact that the sacred book sanctioned slavery blinded many eyes. Instead of asking what was right, men and women asked what the sacred book taught: This was a fearful mistake, which resulted in arraying tens of thousands of as conscientious and kind-hearted people as the world ever saw, on the side of as dark and cruel, and in its spirit unchristian, an institution as has disgraced the modern world.

Such is a specimen of the evils that necessarily come from going back into the past, and taking a book written in an age long gone by, and for an age long gone by, and setting it up as a standard for the present age. It would be false to suggest that slavery was on the way out, or, in spite of some amelioration, that the reformers made any very substantial alterations.

But it is not too much to say that this was a society unafraid of facing its own evils In spite of the vigor of the movement and the depth of its root in Southern tradition, it withered away to almost nothing in a very brief period during the middle thirties.

By there was not one antislavery society remaining in the whole South. Of the thousands of voices that had been raised in outspoken protest a short while before there were to be heard only a few whispers.

Opponents changed their opinions or held their tongues. Loyalty to the South came to be defined in terms of conformity of thought regarding one of its institutions The South concentrated its energies upon the repression of heresy and raised intellectual barricades against the ideas of a critical and unfriendly world.

It happened rather suddenly. The floodstream of criticism dwindled to a trickle and very nearly ceased altogether.Slavery in the United States was the legal institution of human chattel enslavement, primarily of Africans and African Americans, "A necessary evil" In the 19th century, proponents of slavery often defended the institution as a "necessary evil".

White people of that time feared that emancipation of black slaves would have more harmful. To say that slavery was a necessary evil was no reflection upon Southern planters. They had commonly, before , said as much themselves. Many things in this world are necessary evils and are. Nov 24,  · He basically said slavery is a necessary evil, that was from Wikipedia but I'm sure you could put that quote into the search engine and it will pop Status: Resolved.

Slavery As A Necessary Evil Essay Sample. It is inevitable that with the mention of slavery emotions will be aroused within whoever is present.

Today most people look at slavery as one of the biggest mistakes our country has ever made. Dec 03,  · The slavery is evil, is necessary if we accept that all human beings have equal rights. If it was not accepted before , it was because they didn't accept equal rights for human beings.

And slavery was not only about black heartoftexashop.com: Resolved. Feb 15,  · When slavery was most common in the south it was considered a necessary evil. The large plantation owners said that without slaves they wouldn’t be able to harvest the most important cash crop the US had, cotton.

At that time only 25% of the white population owned at least one slave. The majority of that 25% owned less than five.

Slavery - An Evil or a Good?